example of a critical review - 1134 Words

PL4S111 Example: Critical Review of a Journal Article Article: Carroll, J. (2002). Play Therapy: the children’s views, Child and Family Social Work, 7, pg 177-187 This article is recent, published within a peer-reviewed journal. The author-conducted research is empirical, qualitative and phenomenologically designed, uniquely enabling children to describe their play therapy experiences and identify factors that influence these experiences. The article’s title clarifies the project’s purpose of eliciting the child’s view. However, although Carroll clearly describes how children’s experiences should take â€Å"centre stage† (p.178), she hears the opinions of the children’s therapists first, potentially influencing her questioning of the children†¦show more content†¦The accuracy, reliability and comprehensive nature of transcripts is therefore called into question, potentially compromising analysable data. Carroll’s semi-structured questioning may encourage reciprocal communication and perhaps formulated in-depth data. However, she also offers leading questions: â€Å"was that the best thing about it?† (p.180); â€Å"do you think it was helpful playing like that?† (p.184). Such ‘closed’ questions could elicit yes or no responses, or suggest a preferred response. Due to the lack of full transcripts, the reader cannot ascertain whether other leading questions were used and the impact these had on data gathered. Carroll, as interviewer and data analyst, does not consider this risk. As grounded theory was employed by Carroll, data analysis and findings were based on the categorisation of themes. Although Carroll’s data analysis methodology has been deemed appropriate to qualitative research (Strauss, 1997, p. 180), the reader questions whether majority perspectives were favoured over individual for analysis, potentially distorting eventual findings. Carroll outlines categories as a result of her data analysis, providing numerous excerpts from interview transcripts to support her interpretation and analysis of children’s perspectives and to add credibility to her assertions and categorisation. However, the excerpts chosen are mainly positiveShow MoreRelated Critical Reviews of Brave New World Essay example742 Words   |  3 PagesCritical Reviews of Brave New World Since the original publishing of Brave New World, the book has stirred up a brew of controversy. It has received many reviews both positive and negative. In this paper I will provide examples of both and look at the reasons behind them. My first review is a negative one. In the review the reviewer states as his main reasons for disliking the book are the obnoxious characters and plot holes. A few examples of this are that Bernard Marx is unhappy with hisRead MoreCritical Review Whay Most Product Launches Fail Essay example968 Words   |  4 Pageslondon college of accountancy pre-sessional course 2012 | Critical review of ‘why most product launches fail’By Joan Schneider and Julie Hall | Final draft | | Ijaz Khalid302480/402604 | 19/11/2012867 wordsSubmitted to: Barbara Webb | | Critical review Introduction The debut of a product into the market termed as product launch. The product launch signifies the point at which consumers first have access to a new product. But when it comes to new products, great expectationsRead MoreEmployee Motivation Is Critical to the Success of an Organization. Discuss How Managers Motivate Their Employees by Using the Herzbergs Motivation-Hygiene Theory. Illustrate Your Answer with Academic Literature Review and Examples.3041 Words   |  13 Pagessatisfaction are achievement, recognition, and responsibility (Boe, 1970, pp. 99-101). These represent accomplishment, and reinforcement for accomplishment, and increasing challenge, these are the basic components of psychological growth. An example for describing motivator was an employee is given a challenge task and also made responsible to complete that task in his own way, this creates confident. In turn, the employee will do his best to accomplish the task. If as a reward of that achievementRead MoreManuscript Text Or Running Head1672 Words   |  7 PagesManuscript text. In order to maintain anonymity during the peer-review process CCN requires that the author’s name or institution are not included in the manuscript text or running head (AACCN, 2015). An initial literature search was conducted to retrieve resources that where used to examine the topic and develop the outline of the manuscript text. An explanation of the literature search is discussed further below. Upon conducting the literature search, the resources were examined for main themesRead MoreAnalysis of Arthur Millers Death of a Salesman1581 Words   |  6 Pagesin 1949. However, the specific areas of the play that have most intrigued crit ics have changed over time, as different historical, social, and literary concerns lead critics to come up with different interpretations. By analyzing three different critical responses to Death of a Salesman, it will be possible to not only understand the play better, but also actually see how the reception of the play has changed as societys standards of criticism and discourse changed over the intervening years. OneRead More The Role of the Sirens in Homers Odyssey Essay552 Words   |  3 Pagesconstructed by his crew. In their critical review, Horkheimer and Adorno treat the song of the Sirens as a forbidden knowledge of everything. The Sirens represent mans enlightenment. The two writers state, Even though the Sirens know all that has happened, they demand the future as the price of that knowledge, and the promise of the happy return is the deception with which the past ensnares the one who longs for it (Horkheimer and Adorno 48). Even though these critical readers do not mention it, theyRead MoreReview Of  « Accor Group s Environmental Footprint1506 Words   |  7 Pages1/4 Critical review of  « ACCOR Group’s environmental footprint - November 2011 » report, prepared for ACCOR by PwC Background In August 2011, Bleu Safran and Beyond Green Travel were commissioned by ACCOR to undertake a critical review of the study â€Å"ACCOR Group’s environmental footprint† prepared by PwC for ACCOR. The expert panel was formed of the following reviewers: – Costas Christ, one of the world s leading sustainable tourism experts, CEO and founder of Beyond Green Travel (www.beyondgreentravelRead MoreCurrent Open Visitation Practices Within The Critical Care Setting978 Words   |  4 PagesIntroduction. The introduction will provide a contextual overview of the current open visitation practices within the critical care setting. The introduction will begin by highlighting the American Association of Critical-Care Nurses’ and Canadian Association of Critical Care Nurses’ support for open visitation practices and include the argument that unrestrictive family presences is indicative of patient- and family-centered care. Next, the barriers that prevent open visitation and the implicationsRead MoreI have been a San Jose State University student for 4 years now, and over the course of my learning800 Words   |  4 Pagesme to face my fears about writing papers, whether they are short reviews or extensive research papers, I have become more comfortable in writing. I have learned how to write and express myself, how to think for myself, and how to find the answers to the things I don’t know. Most importantly I have learned that revision is essential. I have always been a thinker, but throughout my course work, I have greatly sharpened my critical analysis skills. I realized that breaking up my research when workingRead MoreEssay about Critical Thinking: Evaluation1572 Words   |  7 PagesCritical Evaluation of an Academic Source Odetta Rodriguez Capella University Critical Evaluation of an Academic Source This paper is a summary of critical evaluation of the suitability of an article as an academic source. The title of the article is Critical Thinking: An Extended Definition. The author, Professor Ken Petress, analyzes various definitions of critical thinking and provides his definition of the concept as well. It is vitally